Work.

Historia Civilis3 HN recommenders · 2023–2025
1.7M views · explainer · evergreen · Uploaded 2023-09-29

Historia Civilis traces the history of work and time discipline, comparing modern working hours with those of medieval peasants and the changes brought by clocks and industrialization. It draws on works such as Schor's The Overworked American.

HN uses it in work-hours and four-day-week threads as the source for the claim that people worked fewer hours before the industrial era.

Watch on YouTube

7 comments from Hacker News

@patmorgan232023 · in “How a Four-Day Workweek Works, from the Companies Pulling It Off”

Just watched this interesting video comparing how much we work today to medieval times. [VIDEO] TL;DR we work a LOT more hours now than substance farmers did. They worked 4-6 hours a day and only worked about half of the days out of the year.

RecommendsView on HN
@mharig2024 · in “Ask HN: Alternatives to the Pomodoro technique?”

[VIDEO] But apart from that, I personally need often 1 hour minimum to dive deeply into a problem and spend a considerable amount of time to begin or continue to solve it. I do not think that the pomodoro technique is apropriate for me.

@HeckFeck2024 · in “Childhood Loneliness Linked to Later Psychosis”

The idea that you will be steadily productive 9-5, 5 days a week, for most months of the year, is a post-Industrial expectation. Our ancestors knew mostly "long" days that ended at 5, followed by "slow" days that ended at 12. And the workdays shrunk in later months because there was less daylight. I do wonder if that's part of it - some of us aren't built for conventional work cycles, but most people are and it it is something we can't expect to reshape easily. My source is this video: [VIDEO]

@JumpCrisscross2024 · in “'It's better for humans in general': The 4-day workweek is closer than you think”

> how long ago was the 5 day work week established as the standard? We work unusually hard compared to our ancestors [1]. [1] [VIDEO]

@kolanos2025 · in “X’s director of engineering, Haofei Wang, has left the company”

Here is an excellent video on the history of work. In short, the Dutch screwed it up for all of us. [0] [0]: [VIDEO]

Strongly recommendsView on HN
@GreenWatermelon2025 · in “Jules: An asynchronous coding agent”

Hell, when the industorial revolution happened, working hours increased , not decrease. And especially with electricity, Factory owners forced workers to work deep into the night. A constant 16-hour shift was the norm, so much that it requires legal intervention [1] > In 1833, the Factory Act banned children under 9 from working in the textile industry, and the working hours of 10-13 year olds was limited to 48 hours a week, while 14-18 year olds were limited to 69 hours a week, and 12 hours a day. Government factory inspectors were appointed to enforce the law. Constant work day in and out, morning and night. At least before the industrial revolution farmers only had to work as long as there was daylight, and winters meant shorter work times. This video [2] from Historia Civilis is very relevant. The gist of ot is that to this day, we work more hours than medieval peasants did. [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO]

RecommendsView on HN
@bean4692025 · in “Replacement.ai”

> Average hours worked is more or less monotonically decreasing since the start of the industrial revolution Although that is true when comparing the start of the Industrial revolution and now, people worked less hours before the Industrial revolution [1]. Comparing the hours of work per year in England between the 17th century and the 19th century, there has been an increase of 80%. Most interestingly, the real average weekly wages over the same time period have slightly decreased, while the GDP has increased by 50%. 1. [VIDEO]